Author Archives: J Jacobs

Payback time: the associations of debt and income with medical student career choice

Posted on by
Reply

To read online abstract, click here.

Martha S Grayson, Dale A Newton and Lori F Thompson

Medical Education 2012: 46: 983–991

Context  With impending health care reform in the USA, there is an imperative to increase the number of students choosing primary care (PC) careers. Research is needed to better understand the roles of economic factors in medical student career choice. The objective of this study was to examine the relationships among debt, income and career choice by comparing students planning PC careers with those aspiring to one of the 12 non-PC fields in which median income exceeds US$300 000 (‘high-paying non-primary care’ [HPNPC]).

Methods  Surveys (response rate = 81%) were administered to Year 1 students scheduled to graduate between 1996 and 2012, and Year 4 students graduating between 1993 and 2010. Respondents were students at New York Medical College and East Carolina University’s Brody School of Medicine. Analyses focused on the 2674 Year 1 respondents choosing a PC (n = 1437, 54%) or HPNPC (n = 1237, 46%) career, and the 2307 Year 4 respondents intending to pursue PC (n = 992, 43%) or HPNPC (n = 1315, 57%). Longitudinal analyses examining changes in career goals during medical school were based on students who completed surveys in both Years 1 and 4. The outcome measures studied were self-reported debt, anticipated income and self-rated value placed on income.

Results  Relative to their PC counterparts, students intending to pursue HPNPC careers anticipated an average of US$24 904 (Year 4 students) or US$29 237 (Year 1 students) greater debt, placed a higher importance value on income, and anticipated earning an average of US$58 463 (Year 1 students) and US$89 909 (Year 4 students) more in annual income after graduation. Debt was associated with the value placed on income in the choice of career and the amount of future income anticipated. Students who valued income highly were especially inclined to switch from PC during medical school. The switch away from PC was associated with debt, as well as with a marked increase in anticipated income.

Conclusions  Debt and anticipated income are important concerns which may shape future supplies of PC doctors.

Motivation, learning strategies, participation and medical school performance

Posted on by
Reply

Online abstract click here

Karen M Stegers-Jager, Janke Cohen-Schotanus and Axel P N Themmen

Medical Education 2012: 46:678–688

Context  Medical schools wish to better understand why some students excel academically and others have difficulty in passing medical courses. Components of self-regulated learning (SRL), such as motivational beliefs and learning strategies, as well as participation in scheduled learning activities, have been found to relate to student performance. Although participation may be a form of SRL, little is known about the relationships among motivational beliefs, learning strategies, participation and medical school performance.

Objectives  This study aimed to test and cross-validate a hypothesised model of relationships among motivational beliefs (value and self-efficacy), learning strategies (deep learning and resource management), participation (lecture attendance, skills training attendance and completion of optional study assignments) and Year 1 performance at medical school.

Methods  Year 1 medical students in the cohorts of 2008 (n = 303) and 2009 (n = 369) completed a questionnaire on motivational beliefs and learning strategies (sourced from the Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire) and participation. Year 1 performance was operationalised as students’ average Year 1 course examination grades. Structural equation modelling was used to analyse the data.

Results  Participation and self-efficacy beliefs were positively associated with Year 1 performance (β = 0.78 and β = 0.19, respectively). Deep learning strategies were negatively associated with Year 1 performance (β = − 0.31), but positively related to resource management strategies (β = 0.77), which, in turn, were positively related to participation (β = 0.79). Value beliefs were positively related to deep learning strategies only (β = 0.71). The overall structural model for the 2008 cohort accounted for 47% of the variance in Year 1 grade point average and was cross-validated in the 2009 cohort.

Conclusions  This study suggests that participation mediates the relationships between motivation and learning strategies, and medical school performance. However, participation and self-efficacy beliefs also made unique contributions towards performance. Encouraging participation and strengthening self-efficacy may help to enhance medical student performance.

The only girl in the room: how paradigmatic trajectories deter female students from surgical careers

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Elspeth Hill and Suzanne Vaughan

Objectives

Over 60% of UK medical students are female, yet only 33% of applicants to surgical training are women. Role modelling, differing educational experiences and disidentification in female medical students have been implicated in this disparity. We are yet to fully understand the mechanisms that link students’ experiences with national trends in career choices. We employ a hitherto unused concept from the theory of communities of practice: paradigmatic trajectories. These are visible career paths provided by a community and are cited by Wenger as potentially the most influential factors shaping the learning of newcomers. We pioneer the use of this theoretical tool in answering the research question: How do paradigmatic trajectories shape female medical students’ experiences of surgery and subsequent career intentions?

Methods

This qualitative study comprised a secondary analysis of data sourced from 19 clinical medical students. During individual, in-depth, semi-structured interviews, we explored these students’ experiences at medical school. We carried out thematic analysis using sensitising concepts from communities of practice theory, notably that of ‘paradigmatic trajectories’.

Results

Female students’ experiences of surgery were strongly gendered; they were positioned as ‘other’ in the surgical domain. Four key processes – seeing, hearing, doing and imagining – facilitated the formation of paradigmatic trajectories, on which students could draw when making career decisions. Female students were unable to see or identify with other women in surgery. They heard about challenges to being a female surgeon, lacked experiences of participation, and struggled to imagine a future in which they would be successful surgeons. Thus, based on paradigmatic trajectories constructed from exposure to surgery, they self-selected out of surgical careers. By contrast, male students had experiences of ‘hands-in’ participation and were not marginalised by paradigmatic trajectories.

Conclusions

The concept of the paradigmatic trajectory is a useful theoretical tool with which to understand how students’ experiences shape career decisions. Paradigmatic trajectories within surgery deter female students from embarking on careers in surgery.

Admission criteria and diversity in medical school

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Lotte O’Neill, Maria C Vonsild, Birgitta Wallstedt and Tim Dornan

Context

The under-representation in medical education of students from lower socio-economic backgrounds is an important social issue. There is currently little evidence about whether changes in admission strategies might increase the diversity of the medical student population. Denmark introduced an ‘attribute-based’ admission track to make it easier for students who may not be eligible for admission on the ‘grade-based’ track to be admitted on the basis of attributes other than academic performance. The aim of this research was to examine whether there were significant differences in the social composition of student cohorts admitted via each of the two tracks during the years 2002–2007.

Methods

This prospective cohort study included 1074 medical students admitted during 2002–2007 to the University of Southern Denmark medical school. Of these, 454 were admitted by grade-based selection and 620 were selected on attributes other than grades. To explore the social mix of candidates admitted on each of the two tracks, respectively, we obtained information on social indices associated with educational attainment in Denmark (ethnic origin, father’s education, mother’s education, parenthood, parents living together, parent in receipt of social benefits).

Results

Selection strategy (grade-based or attribute-based) had no statistically significant effect on the social diversity of the medical student population.

Conclusions

The choice of admission criteria may not be very important to widening access and increasing social diversity in medical schools. Attracting a sufficiently diverse applicant pool may represent a better strategy for increasing diversity in the student population.

Metacognitions, worry and attentional control in predicting OSCE performance test anxiety

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Pierce J O’Carroll and Peter Fisher

Objectives  This study investigated the applicability of the self-regulatory executive functioning (S-REF) model to performance test anxiety (PTA) in objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs). Specifically, it examined the relative contributions of metacognitive beliefs, trait worry and attentional control to PTA.

Methods  A cross-sectional design was used. Immediately prior to their formative Communication for Clinical Practice OSCE, 240 Year 1 medical students completed the following self-report questionnaires: the Metacognitions Questionnaire-30 (MCQ-30); the Penn State Worry Questionnaire (PSWQ); the Attentional Control Scale (ACS), and the Performance Test Anxiety questionnaire (PTA).

Results  Univariate analysis indicated that female students scored significantly more highly than male students on the MCQ-30 subscale for negative beliefs about the uncontrollability and danger of worry, the MCQ-30 subscale for cognitive confidence and the PSWQ subscale for trait worry. Partial correlations (controlling for gender) showed that metacognitions, worry and attentional control were significantly correlated with PTA. Multiple regression analyses showed that worry and negative beliefs about the uncontrollability and danger of worry were independent predictors of PTA in both male and female students, whereas attention focus was an independent predictor only in male students.

Conclusions  The findings support predictions derived from the S-REF model that metacognitive beliefs, trait worry and attentional control processes underlie the onset and maintenance of PTA.

Advancing the objective structured clinical examination: sequential testing in theory and practice

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Godfrey Pell, Richard Fuller, Matthew Homer and Trudie Roberts

Context

Models of short-term remediation for failing students are typically associated with improvements in candidate performance at retest. However, the process is costly to deliver, particularly for performance retests with objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs), and there is increasing evidence that these traditional models are associated with the longitudinal underperformance of candidates.

Methods

Rather than a traditional OSCE model, sequential testing involves a shorter ‘screening’ format, with an additional ‘sequential’ test for candidates who fail to meet the screening standard. For those tested twice, overall pass/fail decisions are then based on results on the full sequence of tests. In this study, the impacts of sequential assessment on student performance, cost of assessment delivery and overall reliability were modelled using data sourced from a final graduating OSCE in an undergraduate medical degree programme.

Results

Initial modelling using pre-existing OSCE data predicted significant improvements in reliability in the critical area, reflected in pilot results: 13.5% of students (n = 228) were required to sit the sequential OSCE. One student (0.4%) was identified as representing a false positive result (i.e. under the previous system this student would have passed the OSCE but failed on extended testing). Nine students (3.9%) who would have required OSCE retests under the prior system passed the full sequence and were therefore able to graduate at the normal time without loss of earnings. Overall reliability was estimated as 0.79 for the full test sequence. Significant cost savings were realised.

Conclusions

Sequential testing in OSCEs increases reliability for borderline students because the increased number of observations implies that ‘observed’ student marks are closer to ‘true’ marks. However, the station-level quality of the assessment needs to be sufficiently high for the full benefits in terms of reliability to be achieved. The introduction of such a system has financial benefits, good validity inferences and has proved acceptable to students and other stakeholders.

Does student confidence on multiple-choice question assessments provide useful information?

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Donald A Curtis, Samuel L Lind, Christy K Boscardin and Mark Dellinges

Context

Feedback from multiple-choice question (MCQ) assessments is typically limited to a percentage correct score, from which estimates of student competence are inferred. The students’ confidence in their answers and the potential impact of incorrect answers on clinical care are seldom recorded. Our purpose was to evaluate student confidence in incorrect responses and to establish how confidence was influenced by the potential clinical impact of answers, question type and gender.

Methods

This was an exploratory, cross-sectional study conducted using a convenience sample of 104 Year 3 dental students completing 20 MCQs on implant dentistry. Students were asked to select the most correct response and to indicate their confidence in it for each question. Identifying both correctness and confidence allowed the designation of uninformed (incorrect and not confident) or misinformed (incorrect but confident) responses. In addition to recording correct/incorrect responses and student confidence, faculty staff designated incorrect responses as benign, inappropriate or potentially harmful if applied to clinical care. Question type was identified as factual or complex. Logistic regression was used to evaluate relationships between student confidence, and question type and gender.

Results

Students were misinformed more often than uninformed (22% versus 8%), and misinformed responses were more common with complex than factual questions (p < 0.05). Students were significantly more likely to be confident of correct than incorrect benign, incorrect inappropriate or incorrect harmful answers (p < 0.001), but, contrary to expectations, confidence did not decrease as answers became more harmful.

Conclusions

Recording student confidence was helpful in identifying uninformed versus misinformed responses, which may allow for targeted remediation strategies. Making errors of calibration (confidence and accuracy) more visible may be relevant in feedback for professional development.

Beyond individualism: professional culture and its influence on feedback

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Christopher Watling, Erik Driessen, Cees P M van der Vleuten, Meredith Vanstone and Lorelei Lingard

Context

Although feedback is widely considered essential to learning, its actual influence on learners is variable. Research on responsivity to feedback has tended to focus on individual rather than social or cultural influences on learning. In this study, we explored how feedback is handled within different professional cultures, and how the characteristics and values of a profession shape learners’ responses to feedback.

Methods

Using a constructivist grounded theory approach, we conducted 12 focus groups and nine individual interviews (with a total of 50 participants) across three cultures of professional training in, respectively, music, teacher training and medicine. Constant comparative analysis for recurring themes was conducted iteratively.

Results

Each of the three professional cultures created a distinct context for learning that influenced how feedback was handled. Despite these contextual differences, credibility and constructiveness emerged as critical constants, identified by learners across cultures as essential for feedback to be perceived as meaningful. However, the definitions of credibility and constructiveness were distinct to each professional culture and the cultures varied considerably in how effectively they supported the occurrence of feedback with these critical characteristics.

Conclusions

Professions define credibility and constructiveness in culturally specific ways and create contexts for learning that may either facilitate or constrain the provision of meaningful feedback. Comparison with other professional cultures may offer strategies for creating a productive feedback culture within medical education.

(*Free access) Virtual patient design: exploring what works and why. A grounded theory study

Posted on by
Reply

To read free full article on journal website, click here.

James Bateman, Maggie Allen, Dipti Samani, Jane Kidd and David Davies

Objectives

Virtual patients (VPs) are online representations of clinical cases used in medical education. Widely adopted, they are well placed to teach clinical reasoning skills. International technology standards mean VPs can be created, shared and repurposed between institutions. A systematic review has highlighted the lack of evidence to support which of the numerous VP designs may be effective, and why. We set out to research the influence of VP design on medical undergraduates.

Methods

This is a grounded theory study into the influence of VP design on undergraduate medical students. Following a review of the literature and publicly available VP cases, we identified important design properties. We integrated them into two substantial VPs produced for this research. Using purposeful iterative sampling, 46 medical undergraduates were recruited to participate in six focus groups. Participants completed both VPs, an evaluation and a 1-hour focus group discussion. These were digitally recorded, transcribed and analysed using grounded theory, supported by computer-assisted analysis. Following open, axial and selective coding, we produced a theoretical model describing how students learn from VPs.

Results

We identified a central core phenomenon designated ‘learning from the VP’. This had four categories: VP Construction; External Preconditions; Student–VP Interaction, and Consequences. From these, we constructed a three-layer model describing the interactions of students with VPs. The inner layer consists of the student’s cognitive and behavioural preconditions prior to sitting a case. The middle layer considers the VP as an ‘encoded object’, an e-learning artefact and as a ‘constructed activity’, with associated pedagogic and organisational elements. The outer layer describes cognitive and behavioural change.

Conclusions

This is the first grounded theory study to explore VP design. This original research has produced a model which enhances understanding of how and why the delivery and design of VPs influence learning. The model may be of practical use to authors, institutions and researchers.

Medical students’ tobacco use and attitudes towards tobacco control

Posted on by
Reply

To read on journal website, click here.

Young Kyung Do and Mary Ann Bautista

Context

Despite their important roles as future doctors in tobacco cessation counselling, the high prevalence of tobacco use among medical students may hinder them from advocating tobacco control policies and providing cessation counselling. Promoting this role among medical students is especially important in low- and middle-income countries with high burdens of tobacco use but limited resources for cessation programmes. This study examined the associations between medical students’ tobacco use and their attitudes towards tobacco control policies and the roles of health professionals in the provision of tobacco cessation advice.

Methods

This cross-sectional study included data from the large multi-country dataset generated by the Global Health Professions Student Survey, 2005−2008 (n = 36 533 medical students). Thirteen binary dependent variables related to medical students’ attitudes towards tobacco control policies and the health professional’s role in cessation counselling were examined using random-effects logistic regression, with tobacco use status as the key explanatory variable. Covariates included gender, receipt of cessation training, country-level and gender-specific smoking prevalence, region, and country income group.

Results

Current tobacco use was consistently associated with less favourable attitudes towards tobacco control policy and cessation advice. Compared with never users, daily users were less likely to agree that the sale of tobacco products to adolescents should be banned (odds ratio [OR] 0.45, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.39−0.58) and that health professionals should routinely advise patients to quit smoking (OR = 0.48, 95% CI 0.41−0.52) or other forms of tobacco use (OR = 0.84, 95% CI 0.72−0.97). Daily users were less likely to agree that health professionals who smoke are less likely to advise patients to stop smoking (OR = 0.44, 95% CI 0.39–0.41).

Conclusions

Medical schools may benefit from a thorough re-evaluation of the scope of tobacco cessation training in their curricula in order to support students in smoking cessation and to shape their attitudes towards tobacco control. Targeting medical students who are current tobacco users in tobacco control efforts may be beneficial, given the cost-effectiveness of providing cessation advice.