Reconstructing a lost tradition: the philosophy of medical education in an age of reform

To read on journal website, click here.

 Christopher Martin

Medical Education 2013; 47: 33-39

Context  At the 100th anniversary of Abraham Flexner’s landmark report on medical education, critical reassessment of the direction of medical education reform evinced valuable interdisciplinary contributions from biomedicine, sociology, psychology and education theory. However, to date, philosophy has been absent from the discussion despite its long standing contribution to studies on education in other professions.

Methods  This discussion paper examines how the philosophical tradition can contribute to scholarship in medical education. It begins with an explanation of the scholarly tradition of philosophy of education and its role in thinking in education more generally. It then makes links between this tradition and the context of medical education in the Flexner era of education reform. The paper then argues that this tradition is necessary to the understanding of medical education reform post-Flexner and that doctors must benefit from an education derived from this tradition in order to be able to carry out their work.

Discussion  These foundations are characterised as a hidden, but always present, tradition in medical education. Two ways in which this ‘lost tradition’ can inform medical education theory and practice are identified: firstly, by the establishment of a public canon of medical education texts that express such a tradition, and, secondly, by the incorporation of a variety of ‘signature pedagogies’ exemplary of liberal education.

Poll results: Blog plus LinkedIn!

Thanks to those who voted!

As anticipated, the majority like ‘more options’!

We will work on getting a LinkedIn group up and running early in the new year, and will tweet about it with the #ASME hashtag and announce on LinkedIn and on this blog. Stay tuned and…

…Happy Holidays!

Results for Blog vs LinkedIn

DO YOU PREFER COMMENTING IN LINKEDIN OR ON A PURPOSE-BUILT MEDICAL EDUCATION BLOG?

I prefer to read/post comments on this blog 4 20%
I prefer a LinkedIn group 4 20%
I would like to have both options 12 60%

 

Vodcast on the good, the bad, and the ugly: Media engagement in Medical Education Research

A new vodcast is available!

Two noted medical education researchers, Lynne Monrouxe and Charlotte Rees, share their impressions of the reactions that mass media outlets and social networking sites had to some of their work published in Medical Education.

The article that sparked some fury in the media was from 201145: 261–272 and was entitled “Medical students learning intimate examinations without valid consent: a multicentre study”. The abstract is available by clicking here.

See the video posted on YouTube by clicking here, or play it within the blog, below.

 

Medical Education August 2012 issue posts available for comment!

Hi Everyone,

The posts with abstracts for the August 2012 issue of Medical Education are now available for discussion. Some ideas for comments include:

  • Provide your perspective on and experience with the topic written
  • Share how the article might change your practice or spur your research
  • See who else is engaged in this area of work; ask for collaborators!

If you’d like to jump to the journal website and read the full articles, you can do so by clicking here.

This is meant to be an informal place to bounce around opinions and ideas, so jump on in, and welcome to the conversation!

Josh

ASME ASM 2012 Day 2

For those of you here in Brighton, looks like we’re in store for nicer weather, and another full day of great ideas in medical education.

The reception at the Brighton Museum at the Royal Pavilion was wonderful, with everyone meeting new friends and catching up with old. The setting provided wonderful conversation pieces, and the canapes were delicious (my favorite was the edible spoon!)

Today we will hear from the New Researcher Award winner (Dr. Vicky Tallentire), learn who the winners are for the Silver Quill (Medical Education) and IMPACT (The Clinical Teacher) awards, the traveling fellowship awards, and others. There are several important meetings including the Academy of Medical Educators, the ASME Annual General Meeting, and others. There are concurrent sessions, workshops, poster and exhibit viewing, all capped off by the annual dinner at the Brighton Pier.

Don’t forget to share some of your thoughts on the meeting by leaving a reply to this post.

I’m looking forward to a great day!

Josh

ASME ASM 2012 Day 1

A fantastic start to the ASME annual scientific meeting 2012 here in Brighton! Lots of activity noted on Twitter (#asme2012).

I was lucky enough to attend the USMILE@ME workshop on the use of social media and got some great ideas to implement on the journal websites. Go ahead and Google the USMILE@ME blog and take a look at what this group is doing!

Stop by the ASME journal booth for a chat!

Leave a comment on the blog and be entered to win one of the great lucky draw prizes.

Josh

Good advice from the deputy editors of Medical Education

Kevin Eva

“Editor’s note:

Given their 70 years of cumulative experience as editors and their current processing of over 1400 manuscripts per year, the deputy editors at Medical Education have accumulated many insights regarding common pitfalls that prospective authors should strive to avoid. They share these tricks of the trade routinely as colleagues, consultants and workshop facilitators, but any individual’s reach extends only so far. We want to disseminate their publication tips as broadly as possible because the core goal of our editorial team is to help scholars working within health professional education make their work as good as it can be. To that end, I asked the editors to put fingers to keyboard to briefly share the advice they consider crucial to keep in mind when writing for publication in a scientific journal. Rather than restricting their focus or attempting to engineer coverage of particular topics, I was interested in where the consistencies would lie and in the variety of focus that might arise naturally. I have sequenced their responses chronologically, from comments on the contemplation that should occur before starting to write, through overarching suggestions on the presentation of one’s work, to advice on writing specific sections, ending with a word on strategies for dealing well with requests for revisions. We hope you find these titbits of value and invite you to share additional tips of your own or to pose queries to the editorial team by …”

…leaving a comment in reply to this post :-)

Medical Education July 2012 Issue posts available for comment!

Hi Everyone,

No doubt you’ve received the eTOC (that’s ‘e-Table of Contents’) for the July 2012 issue of Medical Education. The posts are now up on the blog so feel free to join the conversation online with other readers and authors. Some ideas for comments include:

  • Provide your perspective on and experience with the topic written
  • Share how the article might change your practice or spur your research
  • See who else is engaged in this area of work; ask for collaborators!

If you’d like to jump to the journal website and read the full articles, you can do so by clicking here.

This is meant to be an informal place to bounce around opinions and ideas, so jump on in, and welcome to the conversation!

Josh

Medical Education June 2012 Issue posts available for comment!

Hi Everyone,

No doubt you’ve received the eTOC (that’s ‘e-Table of Contents’) for the June 2012 issue of Medical Education. The posts are now up on the blog so feel free to join the conversation online with other readers and authors. Some ideas for comments include:

  • Provide your perspective on and experience with the topic written
  • Share how the article might change your practice or spur your research
  • See who else is engaged in this area of work; ask for collaborators!

If you’d like to jump to the journal website and read the full articles, you can do so by clicking here.

Welcome to the conversation!

Josh